Spiros Mourelatos gave an interview to Mr Vasilis Ignatiadis and Greece’s largest health news portal, iatronet.gr, regarding the causes of this year’s outbreak of West Nile virus, centred on Attica.
We would like to extend our warmest thanks to Mr Ignatiadis and we believe that the information contained in the article contributes to the public debate regarding the emergence of a large number of West Nile virus cases in the Attica region, and in particular in Eastern Attica.
—————————————————————————————————- —————————————————————————————————- ———————————————————–
In 2010, when the West Nile virus had its first major outbreak in Greece, 95% of the cases were located in Central Macedonia. The region combines the presence of a significant wetland – a key stopover point on migratory routes for wild birds – with large areas of rice fields, which provide ideal breeding grounds for mosquitoes, the intermediate hosts of the virus between infected birds and humans.
In 2022, during the third-largest outbreak of the virus to date, Central Macedonia accounted for 82% of all cases nationwide, whilst the overwhelming majority of these cases extended geographically as far as Thessaly.
This year, the picture has been reversed, with 2/3 of all confirmed cases of infection (103 out of 157 as of 19 August) and three-quarters of those with central nervous system symptoms (87 out of 116) being located in Attica. In fact, according to the latest figures from the National Public Health Organisation (EODY) (21 August), 39 of the 59 municipalities classified as affected or high-risk are in Attica, compared with just 11 in Central Macedonia, 7 in Thessaly and one each in the Peloponnese and Central Greece.
“This is not the first time this has happened; in 2014, Attica also accounted for a large proportion of cases,” explains Dr Spiros Mourelatos, head of “Ecodevelopment”, which has been carrying out mosquito monitoring and control programmes for decades with the Region of Central Macedonia in collaboration with the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki. He maps out the epidemic situation for a year that looks set to be one of the worst since 2010, refutes theories that have been put forward in the public debate and offers his own interpretation of this year’s surge.
Two theories under scrutiny
Mr Mourelatos rejects the theory linking the outbreak in Attica to the extreme weather event ‘Daniel’, which occurred in 2023 in Thessaly, and the movement of bird populations further south. “The birds didn’t decide to become urbanised and move from Thessaly to Attica,” he says pointedly, adding: “The virus is now endemic; it is here, and in fact its reservoir consists far more of sparrows and corvids than of migratory birds. At some point, the pathogen arrived via birds migrating between Siberia and South Africa, but it has remained here. It has been here since 2010.”
He also disagrees with the interpretation that the outbreak is due to an increased number of common mosquitoes. “We do not have an increased number of Culex mosquitoes, and it has nothing to do with the number of mosquitoes, but with the proportion of infected ones amongst the total mosquito population,” he notes, explaining why their number alone does not imply a greater circulation of the virus. “In tropical regions, where there are plenty of mosquitoes and birds, there is what we call the spread of the infectious agent: if you have two mosquitoes and both are infected, you’re done for. If you have three infected ones and a hundred uninfected ones, you’ll be protected and the likelihood of becoming infected will be reduced.”
The two phases that influence the circulation of the virus
An epidemic outbreak is the result of many factors and complex processes influenced, amongst other things, by the hydrometeorological conditions of each region, the immunity of birds and their movements, in combination with the two phases – transmission cycles:
- Endozoo-transmission, during spring, is the transmission cycle between birds and mosquitoes.
- Epizootic transmission occurs later, when conditions favour the development of large proportions of infected mosquitoes and the subsequent transmission of the virus to mammals, including humans.
“Last year, only five cases were recorded in Central Macedonia because we had an extremely hot spring – so hot that it prevented the intra-zootic phase from taking place under favourable conditions, and so the epizootic did not occur,” explains the Doctor of Biology, adding: “In contrast, this year we had a wet spring, following a warm winter. A warm winter favours the inter-host cycle – that is, the cycle between birds and mosquitoes – and we may see an outbreak with an abundance of infected mosquitoes that will cause the spillover, the transmission from local birds to mammals.”
The specific hydrometeorological conditions during the winter–spring period favoured the circulation of the virus this year more in Attica and less in Thessaly, Central Macedonia and other parts of the country. It should be noted that birds remain infectious for a period of 1 to 1.5 months. This is roughly the same as the life cycle of mosquitoes, which have a ‘window’ of infectivity lasting approximately 20 days.
Based on the animals serving as indicators of the virus’s circulation and the proportion of infected mosquitoes, Mr Mourelatos estimates that during this season, Central Macedonia will record around 50 cases of West Nile virus, which will be slightly above the average for the last eight years.
You can read the article here.